Schaeffer's Top Stock Picks for '25

Why SPY Is a Better Bet Than VIX Right Now

Traders could play the VIX or the SPY to hedge against a broad-market dip

Oct 13, 2015 at 9:22 AM
facebook X logo linkedin


So, the market has recouped a good chunk of its losses since August, the CBOE Volatility Index (VIX) is back to a 16 full, and you want to hedge and/or play for some downside. What to do? 

Well, you can "buy" the VIX. Except like almost always, you can't actually "buy" VIX at the price of VIX you see on the screen. The futures curve looks like this right now:

151013Warner

 

It's morphing back into the garden-variety upslope we've known and loved. So, sure, you can buy Octobers for $17.20. That sounds good enough -- except they expire in two weeks, so all you accomplish is betting on a relatively quick pop… and you're already 0.75 above the current VIX. There are VIX weeklys now, so you can go closer and shorter too. That's all great if VIX stops now, but doesn't do much to protect a portfolio -- it's just a spec bet that requires good timing. 

I'd rather have more time, but that's going to cost more money. Long story short, none of this appeals to me. 

But then I had a radical thought. What about actual SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) or S&P 500 Index (SPX) options? They all trade with actual implied volatilities that reflect… actual current implied volatility levels! Wow!

OK, I'm being sarcastic. I'd almost always rather just use actual put options or put spreads and "bet" on an actual index. Here's a play from last Friday along those lines from Michael Khouw on CNBC:

"To hedge against a potential turn in the recent rally, Khouw suggested buying a put spread in the S&P 500 ETF, the SPY. Specifically, he looked to purchase the December 200/184 put spread for a total cost of $4.45."

I totally agree with the concept, and I like the timing as well. I'm not predicting we give the downside another test, but IF we do, I'd guess November as to the timing. Just feels like in past cases, the down cycles amidst longer-term upcycles took about three months to play out. So I'd go with December cycle to play it.

The only place I'd really differ is I'd use a tighter strike on the sell side. I'd rather do something like a 200/190 spread and pay less of a debit. Either that or just a straight put buy. I just feel that if it gets back in the low 190s/ high 180s, the out-of-the-money vol is going to spike disproportionately. But that's as much personal preference as anything else; I like the trade.

Disclaimer: Mr. Warner's opinions expressed above do not necessarily represent the views of Schaeffer's Investment Research.

 
 

Which of These SUB-$5 Stocks Could 26x From Here? (AD)

He called a rare 11x on Tesla…

Then he called a 26x on Workhorse…

Then an even rarer 35x on Nio Inc…

Now Tim Bohen says these 5 tiny “America First” stocks are next up in 2025.

They’re trading for less than $5 right now.

But thanks to Elon & Trump’s new alliance…

They could be off to the races in Trump’s first 100 days.

And right now for a limited time…

You can get the names & tickers for just $1 here. (AD)

10 Stock Picks FREE
 
 

Featured Articles from Trusted Partners:

🚀 One Stock Pick Could Change Everything in 2025
What if one stock pick could define your success next year? Get 10 expert-vetted stocks set for 2025—plus 5 bonus picks to watch now. Get the Report →

🆕 New Options Need New Trading Strategies
Zero-DTE options are the newest (and hottest) options to trade.  Professional traders have rushed into the market and are making a mint.  Don’t get left behind - learn all about these options, how to trade them, market setups to profit from, plus much more. Download now →

👀 Revealed: 3 Defensive Stocks for Your Portfolio
Worried about the market? This free report reveals 3 under-the-radar defensive stocks for uncertain times in any kind of economy.

 

 
 

FREE Report Download

 

Follow us on X, Follow us on Twitter